At The Smokin’ Gentleman Lounge, when we sell cigars, it’s the experience that matters most. We provide a sanctuary for exploring stimulating flavors and meaningful conversations. We have curated a selection of complex and flavorful cigars that you can savor in our full-service members’ lounge on Long Island.
Whether you’re looking for a short but meaningful stop to enjoy a unique cigar before dinner in Port Jefferson or a complex tasting session over several weekend hours, we provide the best location and atmosphere to immerse yourself in the moment.
Passionate Curation So You Can Find Better Cigars in Port Jefferson
From stocky box-pressed sticks to stout and round vitolas, every cigar has its own personality. These personalities drive our selection process. Flavor, mouthfeel, aroma, and ingredients are all considered as we stock our precision humidors, ensuring you can visit our lounge for new flavors or revisit recent favorites.
As you develop your palate, you will find preferences and pairings (you could even take a deep dive into cigar and whiskey pairings with this Essential Guide to a Gentleman’s Evening). If you’re looking for something new, or you’re just getting started in the world of premium cigars, we have ten of the best cigars to try right here at our Port Jefferson members’ lounge.
What are the 10 Most Affordable Cigars to Try at our Cigar Lounge in Port Jefferson?
1: The Smokin’ Gentleman Super Premium Toro
Why You Will Love It: Rich, balanced flavors are ideal for relaxation or celebrations.
Try our in-house Super Premium Toro cigars for smoke that stays flavorful without overwhelming the senses. Perfect for long conversations or private reflection. Toros are a gentleman’s perfect companion for when time slows down, and the present is all that matters.
2: New World Connecticut Robusto
Why You Will Love It: It’s creamy in a way that you might not have experienced in the world of cigars.
When folks first visit our cigar lounge from Belle Terre, Setauket, or even Stony Brook, they’re often surprised that cigars aren’t just leather, wood, and heavy smoke. Pick one of these up from our humidor and experience coffee and cream at the forefront of the palate. The warmer flavor of the Connecticut Shade wrapper is an excellent change for anyone looking for something different from the ubiquitous Central American alternatives.
3: Joyo Black Double Robusto
Why You Will Love It: A rich espresso flavor sets this apart from the typical notes of pepper and cocoa. Works perfectly with bright or acidic beverages.
Sometimes you simply want great strength and lasting flavor from a cigar. Joya Blacks offer stacks of it in a Nicaraguan-origin cigar with a San Andreas Maduro Wrapper and select fillers.
4: Stolen Throne 919 Robusto
Why You Will Love It: The Robusta shape is a true classic, and the flavor profile here is also traditional with smoky and leathery notes.
Reasonably priced. Sophisticated. Classic without being boring. That’s what makes this cigar popular with our lounge members coming from areas like Old Field, Stony Brook, Terryville, and other locations around Port Jefferson. This part of Long Island is known for its residents who work hard and take pride in making practical and purposeful decisions. That exact attitude is the same thing that makes Stolen Throne 919 Robusto so good.
5: Alec Bradley Chunk Maduro
Why You Will Love It: Full of flavor and spice that smooths out to a velvety mouthfeel. A perfect choice for those who appreciate stronger cigars.
This bold cigar is physically compact, which is the perfect way to design something with this much flavor. Everything from cocoa and roasted nuts to woody cedar and pepper makes this a real tasting experience.
6: Last Call by AJ Fernandez
Why You Will Love It: The sweeter flavors make this a more modern choice that perfectly pairs with smoke-flavored or zesty drinks.
You can find a little of everything in Last Call cigars, from almonds and hot red peppers to vanilla and milk chocolate. This is a masterfully blended choice. AJ Fernandez Last Call was once a small-batch offering, but demand now makes it more widely available, including here in Port Jefferson, NY.
7: The Smokin’ Gentleman Maduro Gordo
Why You Will Love It: An excellent cigar for the uninitiated, thanks to a peppery profile with smooth cocoa that balances the top notes.
One of our house offerings with a Mexican San Andres wrapper. The Nicaraguan filler is the perfect introduction to the world of cigars, thanks to the balanced flavor. It’s still a great choice for experienced members seeking a daily cigar that pairs well with rich meals and peaty whiskey.
8: Nica Libre Sun Grown Toro
Why You Will Love It: Each box-pressed cigar is a fusion of origin, blending a Haban wrapper, Nicaraguan long-fillers, and Haban binders.
Take the time to enjoy a full-bodied draw with notes of cedar and toasted nuts. Spicy pepper tops the palate to give Nica Libre cigars a sophisticated edginess.
9: My Father Flor de Las Antillas
Why You Will Love It: Nicaraguan origin done in the traditional Cuban way. Considered by many to be the peak of premium cigars.
An award-winning, full-bodied, and box-pressed luxury cigar. Sun-grown Nicaraguan wrappers contain robust cocoa flavor with a note of spice. For a special occasion, My Father Cigars are revered for their quality, flavor, and prestige.
10: Chillin’ Moose Toro
Why You Will Love It: A four-country blend in an Ecuadorian leaf. Flavor profile of leather, cream, spice, and sweet cocoa.
We believe a member’s lounge should be accessible for the daily ritual. People often assume that premium cigars are priced for occasional luxury, but the Chillin’ Moose Toro disproves this perception. It’s a mellow smoke with medium body. Approachable and easy-going, you can enjoy the atmosphere of the lounge with a wallet-friendly cigar. The quality and draw remain premium in every sense.
Take Time for Yourself at Your Local Premium Members’ Only Cigar Lounge
With a range of curated cigar choices, The Smokin’ Gentleman Lounge is your escape from the digital world. Enjoy a comfortable space with knowledgeable staff, friendly members, and a unique experience available any time you want it.
We are a complete lifestyle destination. Our Men’s provisions store houses a curated selection of high-quality accessories from luxury men’s grooming products to handmade hats and caps.
Our lounge is the destination when you want to buy cigars in Port Jefferson, but also seek the chance to truly savor them. Ask about our day pass option as well. We are considered the premier full-service members’ cigar lounge on Long Island. Visit us at 310 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, or call (631) 828-4644.